Exclusive: "Dead rats found in Croydon school's drinking water tank"

Trusted article source icon
Friday, June 12, 2009
Profile image for This is Croydon

This is Croydon

EXCLUSIVE

By Anna Edwards

anna.edwards@essnmedia.co.uk

A former site manager has accused Shirley High of shocking health and safety breaches - including dead rats being found in its drinking water tanks.

Steve Ryan, who worked at the secondary school between October 2008 and April this year, says he came across the vermin in December.

The school insists it has been given a clean bill of health after a Croydon Council inspection in April, although the council's report highlights issues the school needs to work on immediately.

Because Shirley High is a foundation school, its governors are responsible for ensuring the health and safety of the pupils.

Mr Ryan claims the poor water hygiene he found put children at serious risk of Legionnaires' disease.

He said: "I went up on to the science roof to check the cold water tank and found two dead rats in there which I removed.

"The cold water tank provides the school with all its water, the water that comes out of the drinking taps, and Legionella is contracted by dirty water.

"It's a very serious disease, and you've got 900 kids in there and the staff as well, who were in danger."

Mr Ryan had a company internally clean the tank and replace its lining in January.

Croydon Council's April report reveals that in 2006 a Legionella risk assessment was undertaken.

But the company which carried out the safety checks had not inspected all the tanks.

Mr Ryan fears the school's drinking water could have been contaminated for years, as he says no inspections were carried out between 2006 and the one in April.

Croydon Council's latest inspection led to a series of issues being identified for immediate attention.

The report ruled the school had fire doors which needed replacing and that not all staff had been given fire awareness training.

It also revealed there were no heat or smoke detectors in the school's cookery rooms and that the school did not have gas soundness certificates, which show its gas pipes are working properly, since 2007.

Mr Ryan claims he persistently raised his concerns about health and safety with the school.

When his contract was not renewed in April, he wrote to Croydon Council, and as a result its officers carried out the recent inspection.

He said: "I've been doing my job for 25 years so I know what legal requirements a school needs.

"I kept telling them what needed doing but it felt like I was banging my head against a brick wall."

When the Advertiser contacted the school this week we were told headteacher Nigel Barrow was not available to speak as the school was undergoing an Ofsted inspection.

But his PA Jenny Chatfield said: "We were given a clean bill of health by Croydon Council, there is no further comment to make."

Croydon Council confirmed it had acted on Mr Ryan's concerns.

A spokeswoman said: "The local authority has no responsibilities for, and no power to intervene in, pupil health and safety in schools where the governing body is the employer, such as Shirley High.

"Following the allegations, an investigation was launched and the council has advised the school on areas that need to be addressed and this has been reported to the Health and Safety Executive."

10
Tweet this article
Report

10 Comments

  • Profile image for This is Croydon

    by James, Shirley

    Tuesday, June 23 2009, 8:36AM

    “Yes, i agree but my school has been through all the proceders and are clear. there are no concerns for our safety. if you went to any random school in croydon you are likley to find little faults nothing major. no ones perfect!

    How dare poeple make such allegations about MY school!”

  • Profile image for This is Croydon

    by David Garland, Orpington

    Tuesday, June 23 2009, 8:26AM

    “H&S regulations state tanks should be inspected annually and secure lids, vermin guards, etc to protect the tanks. Legionnaires disease is not the worry here but with rats in the water Weill's Disease is a possibility and the whole water testing regime is to be questioned. We are local water hygiene experts and would be pleased to advise Croydon Schools of their obligations with regard to the water tanks and water services.”

  • Profile image for This is Croydon

    by pupil, shirley

    Monday, June 22 2009, 7:39AM

    “(was a crap site staff i mean)”

  • Profile image for This is Croydon

    by pupil at shirley high, shirley

    Monday, June 22 2009, 7:37AM

    “calm down (lol) but yes i agree with you all. he should just go down the job centre and find another job. he cant critisise MY school when he was a sitestaff.”

  • Profile image for This is Croydon

    by Steph, Addington

    Thursday, June 18 2009, 8:06PM

    “I have been a pupil at Shirley high school for nearly 3 years now and i haven't been ill because of the water when i drink it from the fountains..
    and the only reason mr ryan didn't get his contract updated was because he didn't do his job properly so he got all fed up and started to act like a right ass. his acting like a 5 year old to be honest

    Stephanie,
    New Addington”

  • Profile image for This is Croydon

    by Anon., CROYDON

    Monday, June 15 2009, 11:30AM

    “Look the main concern here is the kids (one of which is my daughter currently in the school).

    Mr Ryan claims to have found two rats in the tank, surely thats the most signifcant thing here. & the fact that the school has emergancy fire doors that need changing, 'NO' smoke detectors in the cooking rooms, & not all staff fire safety trained??? ( all of which failed in the current April school inspection).

    So its not looking like a guy that is just miserable because he lost his job. What about these other faults?? The school is definately failing its pupils and i for one will be making my own investigations in to what will be done!!!”

  • Profile image for This is Croydon

    by Anon, Croydon

    Saturday, June 13 2009, 7:55PM

    “Shirley has a clean bill of health. Steve just can't accept he lost the job. To 'rat' on him, what about the regular secret smokes he had on a strictly non-smoking site. Where's the health and safety in that?”

  • Profile image for This is Croydon

    by Paige, Croydon

    Friday, June 12 2009, 12:57PM

    “this is so stupid! i agree with Amelia surely if there was such a worry the school would have shut. this article makes it seem like Shirley high couldn't care about its staff and pupils but i know that Shirleys main priority is the safety of us pupils.”

  • Profile image for This is Croydon

    by Amelia, Shirley

    Friday, June 12 2009, 12:14PM

    “I agree with James.

    If this was such a health and safety concern, i swear the school would have been such down straight away?

    I hate how people keep trying to make Shirley High seem like a bad school, obviously nothing else to publish in the papers.”

  • Profile image for This is Croydon

    by James Maragh, Shirley

    Friday, June 12 2009, 7:43AM

    “I think this is just highly exaggerated because Mr.Ryan didnt get his contract renewed.

    My school would have been closed by health & saftey people if it was a huge concern.

    Regards,

    James Maragh

    shirley high school pupil.”

        Your comments awaiting moderation

        Add your comments

        max 4000 characters