Hospital says sorry after mistakes that "nearly killed" newborn baby

Trusted article source icon
Friday, August 13, 2010
Profile image for This is Croydon

This is Croydon

EXCLUSIVE

By Cherry Wilson

cherry.wilson@essnmedia.co.uk

A MOTHER and her baby nearly died during labour after being left alone with a student midwife – who was only on her second day in the job.

Saima Fiaz and her son Nauman Saqib, from Upper Norwood, were left fighting for their lives following mistakes made at St George's Hospital.

When Mrs Fiaz, of Spa Hill, started experiencing severe pain, the trainee called in another midwife who told her it was probably because the baby was coming.

An examination was not carried out, and further help was only sought when a monitor started flashing showing the baby's heart rate was going down.

An emergency operation was then carried out, but Nauman was left starved of oxygen for at least ten minutes.

As 29-year-old Mrs Fiaz had a caesarean for the birth of her eldest son, Zidane, 3, she was considered a "high risk" patient, but she was still left with only the student midwife as she was in the early stages of giving birth.

This week the hospital in Tooting apologised and admitted it did not adequately inform Mrs Fiaz of the risks of having a normal birth after a caesarean.

The pain she was experiencing was from the scar from her first labour ripping open as she started to give birth to Nauman, and this led to her unborn son being left without oxygen.

Mrs Fiaz and her husband, Saqib Thandi, have now been told they cannot have any more children.

Bus driver Mr Thandi said: "My wife and son could have died because of their negligence.

"We'll never be able to get over this. How can we forgive them for this tragic incident?

"We were going to have another baby. These people have destroyed my whole family life."

The parents now face an agonising wait to find out if Nauman has suffered any disabilities as a result of being without oxygen for so long. He will have to undergo regular check-ups for the next five years.

Mrs Fiaz said: "I can never forgive them. We could have died. I'm angry and upset for my baby."

An investigation was launched into the care Mrs Fiaz received following the birth of her son on February 19.

This week the hospital admitted it had been at fault and that Mrs Fiaz should not have been left alone with a student midwife.

A spokesman for St George's Healthcare NHS Trust said: "The trust accepts the communication with the parents about what was a high risk birth should have been better. We have carried out a full investigation and have taken measures to ensure new guidelines for discussing risks with parents are put in place."

14
Tweet this article
Report

14 Comments

  • Profile image for This is Croydon

    by Concerned, South London

    Friday, August 20 2010, 8:16PM

    “''I can never forgive them'' ....how now to forward for anyone ?”

  • Profile image for This is Croydon

    by Jo, Croydon

    Thursday, August 19 2010, 4:09PM

    “One less immirgrant to be born in this country!!”

  • Profile image for This is Croydon

    by Mike, Ex Croydon

    Wednesday, August 18 2010, 3:39PM

    “Testman

    What I was trying to say is that we need to plan for the changes in the way numbers in births are affected by the changed make up of our nation sorry if I was clumsey in the way I did this.”

  • Profile image for This is Croydon

    by midwife, Croydon

    Wednesday, August 18 2010, 3:00PM

    “it sounds as the student midwife here was the most 'clever person' as he/she called for help, whether the appropriate help was not given we can't say, a newspaper article does not give enough insight, but I am sure the formal investigation will have looked at these things.
    What the article does not say is that we are extremely understaffed and under-resourced in the NHS (I work in it and have done for over 10 years, mainly on labour wards) and that midwives are supposed to give 'high quality- one to one care' in labour but often are MADE to look after 2 or 3 women with not enough or not the right equipment, in those circumstances things get overlooked and mistakes happen, not because the midwife is not 'capable' but because it's just impossible to be in 3 rooms at the same time!
    yes we tell the managers and the person in charge of the shift, after 10 years of doing that it's still NOT changing, what else can we do? if we refuse to look after the women it will be even worse? maybe not, maybe we need to go on strike for these appalling work conditions to END? midwives women children and their families are suffering!”

  • Profile image for This is Croydon

    by Test Man, London

    Monday, August 16 2010, 1:44PM

    “Mike, I'm amazed that you somehow managed to work "immigration" into this story. Some of your comments I like but come on, lets not clutch at straws here.”

  • Profile image for This is Croydon

    by Mike, Ex Croydon

    Sunday, August 15 2010, 10:29AM

    “The good news is that the mother and baby are fit and healthy and that the hospital has admitted their error. The thing we need to remember is that the rise in births in some areas and this does appear in areas with a higher than average in areas that increased number of immigrants whether they be from within Europe or further afield is putting a great deal of pressure on hospitals and there are not enough mid-wife¿s across many parts of the country and because of the increased in litigation people appear to be moving out of the midwifery side of nursing.”

  • Profile image for This is Croydon

    by Krystal, New Addington

    Saturday, August 14 2010, 2:12PM

    “Jeez - you lot are truly heartless.

    I doesn't matter what the colour of their skin, and for the Hospital to have actually admitted negligence the standard of care and failure to follow procedure MUST have been poor.

    Please also note - the Father is working and supporting his family, and to have the right to have another child taken away from them must be very hard to accept - and I'm sure they feel all the more blessed for the children they already have.

    Though Nauman may have survived the birth, it remains to be seen of he reaches his milestones in development as he should - brain damage is not always detectable immediately.

    As to whether the compensation game is played is their decision - though I hope it will only be if the baby shows signs of needing extra support.

    I do remain astounded at some of the comments on here - anyone of you who have children should maybe think how you would feel had any of the births had been like this one.”

  • Profile image for This is Croydon

    by John Roberts, Croydon

    Saturday, August 14 2010, 1:18PM

    “The question is, would they have received such disgusting treatment if they were white people?”

  • Profile image for This is Croydon

    by hmmmm, croydon

    Friday, August 13 2010, 11:16PM

    “She would of had to agree to have a student in the room for starters, I know this hospital very well. And also it is a teaching hospital. Also if they have been told they cant have any more children(which it says in the story) then enjoy what you do have, children are a gift, and these people are lucky to have children. Glad the baby is ok.”

  • Profile image for This is Croydon

    by Fruitbat, South Norwood

    Friday, August 13 2010, 10:47PM

    “.....nearly died????? But didn't die. mmmmmmmmm.
    They were going to have another baby. Why? - they've got two. Many couples would like to have one child but can't.
    Stop whining and think how lucky you are!”

        Your comments awaiting moderation

        Add your comments

        max 4000 characters